Chemical work convention

Fixes the sign of the chemical potential term in the energy balance for open systems.
Chemical work convention

Definition and physical meaning

For an , the NN can change as matter crosses the . The energetic effect of this exchange is governed by the μ\mu.

In the differential form of the for a single-component simple system, the reversible change in internal energy includes the term μdN\mu\,dN:

dU=TdSPdV+μdN. dU = T\,dS - P\,dV + \mu\, dN.

Physically, μ\mu is the energy change associated with adding particles to the system at fixed entropy and volume (for the reversible/quasistatic setting).

Convention used in this blog

We keep the as for mechanical work: δW>0\delta W>0 means work done by the system. With that choice, it is often convenient to treat particle exchange as a kind of generalized work and define the chemical work (by the system) as

  • Single species: δWchem:=μdN\delta W_{\mathrm{chem}} := -\mu\, dN,
  • Multiple species: δWchem:=iμidNi\delta W_{\mathrm{chem}} := -\sum_i \mu_i\, dN_i.

This definition is chosen so that when particles enter the system (dN>0dN>0), the system receives energy and the work done by the system is negative: δWchem<0\delta W_{\mathrm{chem}}<0.

With pressure–volume work included via the , the can be written in the “work by the system” form as

dU=δQ(δWPV+δWchem)=δQPextdV+iμidNi. dU = \delta Q - \bigl(\delta W_{PV} + \delta W_{\mathrm{chem}}\bigr) = \delta Q - P_{\mathrm{ext}}\, dV + \sum_i \mu_i\, dN_i.

Key relations and common consequences

  • Grand potential sign check: with Ω:=UTSiμiNi\Omega := U - TS - \sum_i \mu_i N_i, this convention leads to

    dΩ=SdTPdViNidμi d\Omega = -S\, dT - P\, dV - \sum_i N_i\, d\mu_i

    for reversible variations, matching the natural variables (T,V,μi)(T,V,\mu_i) used in the .

  • Translation to “work on the system” convention: if instead one writes dU=δQ+δW(on)dU=\delta Q+\delta W^{(\mathrm{on})}, then the chemical contribution is typically taken as δWchem(on)=+iμidNi\delta W^{(\mathrm{on})}_{\mathrm{chem}}=+\sum_i \mu_i\, dN_i.

  • Interpretation as reservoir exchange: the μdN\mu\,dN term corresponds to energy transferred with matter from a particle reservoir (sometimes informally called a “chemical reservoir”), just as TdST\,dS corresponds to exchange with a .