Canonical: https://knowlpedia.com/real-analysis/cylindrical-axis-regularity/

# A sufficient criterion for smoothness at a cylindrical axis

Smooth dependence on r squared with the correct component factors yields smooth Cartesian fields.

Let \(a(s,z),b(s,z),c(s,z)\) be [smooth](https://knowlpedia.com/real-analysis/class-ck-map/) on an open neighborhood of the relevant points with \(s\ge0\). An axisymmetric field on \(r>0\) with
\[
u_r=r\,a(r^2,z),\qquad
u_\theta=r\,b(r^2,z),\qquad
u_z=c(r^2,z)
\]
extends smoothly through the axis.

## Cartesian verification

Putting \(s=x^2+y^2\), its Cartesian components are
\[
u_x=x\,a(s,z)-y\,b(s,z),\qquad
u_y=y\,a(s,z)+x\,b(s,z),\qquad
u_z=c(s,z).
\]
These are compositions and products of smooth functions. This proves the stated sufficient criterion directly, including parameter-dependent versions when \(a,b,c\) are jointly smooth in those parameters.

## Why radial smoothness alone is insufficient

The field \(e_r=(x/r,y/r,0)\) has constant cylindrical radial component but no continuous extension at zero. Even a scalar \(f(r)=r\), smooth on the radial half-line in its one-sided sense, becomes \(\sqrt{x^2+y^2}\), which is not differentiable at the axis.
