Proposition. Let (X,d)(X,d) be a metric space and let AXA\subset X. Then for aXa\in X,

aA (an)A with ana.a\in \overline{A}\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \exists\ (a_n)\subset A \text{ with } a_n\to a.
Remarks

Context. This is a specifically metric phenomenon (first-countability): the topological notion of can be detected by sequences.

Proof sketch.

  • If aAa\in\overline{A}, then by each ball B(a;1/n)B(a;1/n) meets AA; pick anAB(a;1/n)a_n\in A\cap B(a;1/n) to get anaa_n\to a.
  • Conversely, if anAa_n\in A and anaa_n\to a, then every ball around aa contains some ana_n, hence meets AA, so aAa\in\overline{A}.